About
Foundational Principles In the Community Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Technical Excellence Alumni TIAG Membership
Careers
Why Cohen & Co Our Culture Total Rewards & Benefits Early Career Opportunities Experienced Opportunities Join Our Talent Community
Contact
Akron, OH Baltimore, MD Buffalo, NY Chicago, IL Cleveland, OH Deer Park, IL Denver, CO Detroit, MI Milwaukee, WI New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Pittsburgh, PA St. Clair Shores, MI Youngstown, OH
Client Portal
Services Industries Knowledge Center People

About Our Services

We offer tailored solutions — whether private company or owner; public or private fund, adviser or fund service provider; or Fortune 1000 enterprise. Learn how we can help you.

Find Services

Assurance Services

Employee Benefit Plan Audits Internal Controls Investment Company Audits Private Company Audits

Tax Services

Federal Tax Planning & Compliance High Net Worth & Wealth Transfer International Filings & Structuring Investment Company Tax State & Local Tax Tax Credits & Incentives Transaction Tax Planning

Advisory Services

Business Valuations Data & Insights Digital Finance Solutions IT Strategy & Implementation Litigation Support Services M&A Advisory Outsourced Accounting Solutions Transaction Services Turnaround & Restructuring

Our Industry Expertise

Our industry experience means you can find professionals who speak your language and bring earned insights to the table. Learn how we can help you.

Explore Industries

Key Industries

Digital Assets Investment Companies Manufacturing Private Companies Private Equity Real Estate & Construction Technology & Life Science
VIEW THE COMPLETE LIST

Knowledge Center

Our team wants to help your team stay up to date. Browse our thought leadership, events and news for insights and a point of view on business-critical topics.

Find Insights & Events

Insights

Browse valuable articles and publications our experts have written to help you and your organization answer key questions — and consider new ones.

Read Our Insights

Events

Join us in person and online for events that address timely topics and key business considerations.

Explore Our Events

News

Find out what is happening at Cohen & Co, from industry recognitions and growth updates, to where we are contributing to important media stories.

Read Our News
People
Foundational Principles In the Community Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Technical Excellence Alumni TIAG Membership
Why Cohen & Co Our Culture Total Rewards & Benefits Early Career Opportunities Experienced Opportunities Join Our Talent Community
Akron, OH Baltimore, MD Buffalo, NY Chicago, IL Cleveland, OH Deer Park, IL Denver, CO Detroit, MI Milwaukee, WI New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Pittsburgh, PA St. Clair Shores, MI Youngstown, OH
Client Portal
Back to Insights

ASU 2018-08 Clarifies Whether to Recognize Your Not-for-Profit’s Revenue as a Contribution or Exchange

by Steve Guarini

June 16, 2020 Not-for-Profit


Have you ever heard someone say: “Nonprofit accounting? Oh, that’s easy”? To that I say, HA! Whether it’s accounting for endowments in accordance with UPMIFA, determining how to value in-kind donations or dealing with donor restrictions, nonprofit organizations can have some very challenging accounting issues.

One of those perplexing issues has always been determining whether to account for a revenue transaction as a contribution or an “exchange.” The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) has come to the rescue with ASU 2018-08, which provides more guidance on when transactions are contributions versus exchange transactions.

Why Is It Important to Know Whether Your Transaction is a Contribution or an Exchange?

Under GAAP, non-exchange, or “contribution” transactions are recognized as revenue immediately in the period the pledge or cash contribution is made. With contributions, there is no assessment of whether there is a customer, which obligation(s) have to be met before the revenue is recognized, or whether the revenue should be recognized at some point in time or over some period of time. None of those activities are required under ASC 958, which governs accounting for contributions.

Under ASU 2018-08, if you don’t have a contribution, then you have an “exchange” transaction that must be accounted for under ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts With Customers. Revenue transactions under ASC 606 are much more complex than the simple immediate recognition of contributions.

Read “How to Create Your Revenue Recognition Accounting Policy and Prepare for the New Disclosures”

What is an Exchange Transaction and Why Is Commensurate Value So Important?

An exchange transaction is one in which there is a commensurate (reciprocal) exchange of value between the nonprofit and a resource provider. These transactions are essentially the same in nature as those engaged in by commercial entities. An easy to understand example is tuition revenue of a private school. The school charges tuition and in turn provides a specified period of education for the student.  The tuition paid represents commensurate value for the education provided (a reciprocal exchange of value), and we have an exchange transaction to be accounted for under ASC 606. That sounds pretty straight forward, right? So why did we even need ASU 2018-08 for guidance?

While some exchange transactions are pretty obvious, such as the above tuition example, others are not. The most common type of transactions that caused disparity in practice were transactions with government entities. Some believed that governmental entities could not give a “contribution” and that all such transactions were exchanges in nature, while others did not. ASU 2018-08 helps settle this disparity.

Under ASU 2018-08, if the benefit of the nonprofit activity paid for by a governmental entity is received by the general public, rather than the government itself, the arrangement is not an exchange of commensurate value and the transaction is non-exchange. On the other hand, if the governmental entity identifies specific beneficiaries of the nonprofit’s services, then the arrangement is considered to be an exchange. An example would be where a county mental health authority provides a nonprofit clinic with a capitated payment to provide services to specified persons who are registered with that authority. Contrast that with a grant from the same authority to the nonprofit clinic for general program operations, which would be a contribution.

4 Transaction Categories to Help You Decide

The guidance under ASU 2018-08 clarifies whether a transaction is an exchange in nature or not by breaking transactions into four groups:

  1. There is direct commensurate value to the resource provider (exchange)
  2. The resource provider has identified specified customers to which its payment relates (exchange)
  3. The resource provider identifies groups of beneficiaries with eligibility criteria (non-exchange)
  4. The benefit provided by the nonprofit is to the general public (non-exchange)


With a solid of “commensurate value” and how it impacts your revenue recognition, as well as the additional guidance offered by ASU 2018-08, it should be easier to determine what type of transaction you are trying to record for your not-for-profit. The ASU is effective for nonprofits with fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2018.

Contact Steve Guarini or a member of your service team to discuss this topic further.

Cohen & Co is not rendering legal, accounting or other professional advice. Information contained in this post is considered accurate as of the date of publishing. Any action taken based on information in this blog should be taken only after a detailed review of the specific facts, circumstances and current law with your professional advisers.

About the Author

Steve Guarini, CPA

Partner, Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC
Partner, Cohen & Company, Ltd.
sguarini@cohenco.com
586.541.7736
Sign Up for Our Emails & Events

Receive insights from our specialists in a variety of areas and timely information on upcoming events directly to your inbox as they go live in our online Knowledge Center.

Subscribe Today
Top
Subscribe to our newsletter
About Contact Submit RFP Privacy Policy

"Cohen & Co" is the brand name under which Cohen & Company, Ltd. and Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC, and its subsidiary entities, provide professional services.

Cohen & Company, Ltd. and Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC practice in an alternative practice structure in accordance with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct and applicable law, regulations and professional standards.

Cohen & Company, Ltd. is a licensed independent CPA firm that provides attest services to its clients. Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC and its subsidiary entities provide tax, advisory and business consulting services to their clients and are not licensed CPA firms.

The entities operating under the Cohen & Co brand are independently owned and are not responsible for the services provided by any other entity operating under the Cohen & Co brand. Our use of terms such as “our firm,” “we,” “us” and other terms of similar import denote the alternative practice structure of Cohen & Company, Ltd. and Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC.

© 2025 Cohen & Co